본문 바로가기

공감

타이틀공지사항

South Korea Moving to Shut the Narrow Door to Refugee Recognition

A few years ago, we shared the story of an asylum seeker from Russia who, with the support of GongGam, defied the odds to be recognized as a refugee in Korea.

It remains extremely difficult to be recognized as a refugee in Korea. According to statistics from the Ministry of Justice, only 112 out of 7,404 applications (1.5%) were accepted at first instance in 2025, and only 7 out of 3,387 applications (0.2%) were accepted on appeal. Only 16 people were recognized as refugees through litigation.

In Korea, even applying for asylum is not easy. Some immigration offices have only one counter for processing refugee applications, and the waiting tickets run out early in the morning. If an applicant already holds a valid visa, they are often turned away with the explanation that “there is no need to apply for refugee status at this time.” However, if they apply shortly before their visa expires, their application is deemed “abusive” and they are not provided a visa, preventing them from working legally. If they work illegally to survive and are caught, they can be detained in immigration detention for up to 20 months.

The definition of “refugee” under international law is the same in every country. Globally, the average refugee recognition rate is estimated to be in the 30% range annually, while in Europe it is in the 40% range; in countries such as Canada and Austria, it can reach 60–80%. However, in South Korea, it is only 0–2%. The Korean government claims this is because there are an unusually high number of “fake refugees” in South Korea. However, there are bound to be people in any country who seek to abuse the refugee system. The real reason is that the Korean government interprets the definition of “refugee” under international law arbitrarily narrowly and requires an excessively high standard of proof for asylum seekers.

However, rather than reforming Korea’s failed refugee protection system to bring it into line with international standards, the Korean government and the National Assembly are attempting to further shut the already narrow door to refugee recognition. The three amendments to the Refugee Act currently pending in the National Assembly are designed to exclude “persons posing a threat to national interest” from refugee recognition or to enable the swift rejection of “abusive applications.” The sponsors of these three bills are the government, the opposition party, and the ruling party, respectively. So regardless of political affiliation, they are all seeking to further curtail protection for refugees.

The amendment to the Refugee Act proposed in March of this year (led by Rep. Kim Ki-pyo), for the first time seeks to introduce a system for “dismissal” of refugee applications. The rationale is that the abusive applications have caused delays, resulting in “genuine refugees not receiving timely protection”, so the amendment will improve the efficiency of the RSD process. If the bill is passed, the Ministry of Justice will be able to immediately reject applications that fall under the grounds for dismissal without conducting a substantive, individual review of the applications.

This amendment will likely violate the principle of non-refoulement, stipulated in international treaties such as the Refugee Convention, the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, and the Convention against Torture, and also recognized as customary international law. This is because dismissing a refugee application on formal or superficial grounds without conducting a substantive and individual assessment of the risk of persecution, torture, or violations of the right to life upon repatriation constitutes a failure as a State party to take adequate measures to respect the principle of non-refoulement under international law.

In fact, the UN Human Rights Committee recently decided that the Korean government’s refusal to accept a refugee application from an asylum-seeker from the Democratic Republic of the Congo—on the sole ground that the individual was a transit passenger—resulting in the asylum-seeker being forced to live in the transit area of Incheon International Airport for over 14 months, constituted a violation of the principle of non-refoulement under Article 7 of the ICCPR.

Republic of Korea violated rights of asylum seeker held in limbo at Incheon airport, UN committee finds

While the system for dismissing refugee applications is problematic in itself, the grounds for dismissal listed in the bill are also problematic. The first ground for dismissal applies to cases where it is clearly established that the applicant filed a refugee application by concealing facts through false documents or false statements. While this may seem reasonable at first glance, it completely fails to take into account the unique circumstances of refugees. In cases where they must flee urgently or are facing persecution by their home government, they may be unable to obtain official passports or entry/exit permits and may be forced to use false travel documents. Furthermore, due to trauma or distrust of government officials due to experiences in their home country, they may conceal facts or make false statements when initially applying for refugee status. If applications are dismissed solely on these grounds, it will inevitably result in the forced repatriation of people who are actually at risk of persecution or torture.

In my experience, the most vulnerable refugees are at a higher risk of having their applications dismissed for these reasons. If they faced severe social stigma or had negative experiences with authority figures in their home country, they may find it difficult to speak honestly about their experiences of persecution, not only to immigration officials but also to NGOs. Furthermore, those who are illiterate or have low literacy often struggle to complete the complex refugee application form and navigate the application process on their own, making them vulnerable to brokers who offer to file applications on their behalf for a fee.

That is why the UN Refugee Agency emphasizes that even if a refugee claim appears to be “manifestly unfounded” or “clearly fraudulent,” the applicant must be guaranteed the procedural right to at least a minimal examination of the merits of the case. This is because forcibly returning someone to their home country, where they claim to face a risk of persecution or torture, is such a grave decision.

Other grounds for dismissing refugee applications listed in the bill are restrictions on reapplying for refugee status without a significant change in circumstances, and failure to comply with attendance requirements—such as for refugee interviews—on three or more occasions. The government has previously attempted to pass legislation restricting re-applications for refugee status, but these efforts failed due to opposition from the National Human Rights Commission, the UNHCR, and domestic and international human rights organizations. Also, the provision regarding failure to comply with attendance requirements three or more times is ineffective, as the process can already be terminated under Article 8, Paragraph 6 of the current Refugee Act.

The primary justification for the government and the National Assembly for continuing to push such amendments—which would scale back refugee protection even further—is “public opinion.” The Ministry of Justice’s Refugee Policy Division claims that, based on public opinion polls, the majority of the public supports these amendments. Their explanatory materials submitted to the National Assembly still emphasize the number of people who signed a public petition against accepting refugees during the so-called “Yemeni refugee crisis” in 2018.

Setting aside the question of whether it is appropriate to justify issues concerning someone’s basic human rights on the grounds of “administrative efficiency” or “public opinion,” I believe that if citizens were to meet the people who come to Korea to apply for refugee status and hear their stories firsthand, they would not be able to so easily tell them to “go back to your own country.” This is because these stories are not so unfamiliar. People opposing authoritarian regimes, people fighting for their nation’s right to self-determination, people standing up against religious persecution, people striving to preserve their identity—these are stories that can be found in both Korea’s past and present.

Ultimately, if we are to change the policy direction of the government and the National Assembly—which seeks to close the narrow door to refugee recognition—citizens must speak out. We must strive to understand refugees and recognize how Korea’s policy of “not accepting refugees” actually affects people’s lives. I hope that we can show policymakers that public opinion is not what they assume it to be.

Written by Ji Yoon Kang