공지사항
Enforced Disappearances Not a Story from a Distant Land or a Distant Past – On the Submission of Joint Report by South Korean Human Rights Organizations to the UN Committee on Enforced Disappearances
South Korea recently ratified and acceded to the International Convention for the Protection of All Persons from Enforced Disappearance, one of the core international human rights treaties. Under the Convention, enforced disappearance is defined as “the arrest, detention, abduction, or any other form of deprivation of liberty by a state agency or by a person or group of persons acting with the authorization, support, or acquiescence of the state, followed by a denial of such deprivation of liberty or concealment of the fate or whereabouts of the disappeared person, thereby placing the person outside the protection of the law.” In other words, it refers not merely to simple arrest, detention, or abduction, but to cases where the state leads, encourages, or neglects such actions, thereby making legal protection impossible in law or in practice.
The Committee on Enforced Disappearances, the treaty body for the Convention, reviews reports submitted by states, prepares a list of issues, requests additional reports from the state, and then conducts an in-person review. During this process, human rights organizations submit their own NGO reports and convey their views directly to the committee members both before and after the review. Late last year, ahead of the Committee’s adoption of a list of issues for South Korea, GongGam submitted an NGO report in collaboration with other human rights organizations. GongGam primarily addressed the following issues: 1) the domestic effect of international human rights treaties, 2) the National Human Rights Commission of Korea, 3) draft domestic implementing legislation, 4) the prohibition of forced return, 5) the detention of migrants, 6) the secret detention of North Korean defectors, and 7) human rights violations in international adoption.
The Committee will adopt a list of questions for South Korea during its March session and will conduct the in-person review in the second half of this year or next year. GongGam plans to continue raising concerns, in collaboration with domestic and international human rights organizations, regarding all domestic human rights issues where enforced disappearances have been a problem, as well as issues related to historical injustices and detention facilities.

[Excerpt from the Joint NGO Submission]
“Despite Article 6(1) of the Constitution, which provides that treaties duly concluded and promulgated shall have the same effect as domestic law, there are very few cases in which constitutional, civil, criminal, or administrative courts have directly addressed violations of UN human rights treaties, including the Convention. In some cases, such treaties have been mentioned only in dissenting/concurring opinions or applied indirectly in conjunction with constitutional provisions or domestic statutes. There is no known case in which a judgment was based solely on a violation of an international human rights treaty.
…
Following the unlawful declaration of martial law in late 2024, which involved attempts at enforced disappearance, the NHRCK remained silent regarding the grave risk of enforced disappearance and other serious human rights violations. Instead, it emphasized the procedural rights of the President who declared the unlawful martial law and the military forces that sought to execute it, thereby effectively defending the unlawful declaration of martial law. This revealed serious institutional shortcomings.
…
Two bills on the implementation of the Convention are currently pending before the National Assembly: one proposed by Representative Kim Gi-hyeon and another by Representative Kim Young-bae. The former is identical to the amended bill proposed by the Government in the previous Assembly. However, the definition of enforced disappearance in the Kim Gi-hyeon’s bill, which is effectively endorsed by the Government, omits the element of “refusal to acknowledge deprivation of liberty.
…
Over the past five years, the refugee recognition rate in ROK has remained between 0 and 2%. Refugee applicants must submit their applications solely in Korean or English without receiving any interpretation, translation, or legal support during the application process. The lack of sufficient human and material resources hinders the operation of a thorough and professional refugee status determination process. Furthermore, the failure to provide applicants with video recordings of refugee interviews and refugee determination reports prevents the operation of a fair and transparent refugee status determination process. From the second refugee application, ROK uniformly issued departure orders to all applicants, suspending enforcement only during the refugee application period. This renders employment impossible and leaves applicants without identity documents, effectively subjecting them to pressure for forced return. If a second time refugee applicant is caught working, they receive a deportation order and are detained in an immigration detention center until deportation. In May 2025, a case was reported in the media where ROK attempted to forcibly repatriate an applicant preparing an appeal after his application was rejected. This demonstrates the risk that applicants face being forcibly returned to their countries where they could face enforced disappearance.
…
In 2023, the Constitutional Court ruled unconstitutional a provision of the Immigration Control Act that had allowed for indefinite detention of migrants. Although the law has since been amended and implemented, detention of up to 20 months remains possible without adequate consideration of a reasonable period for deportation, even in cases where forced removal cannot be executed within a reasonable period, such as when refugee application or related litigation is pending. The committee responsible for determining the legality of detention extensions or suspensions is established under the Ministry of Justice, thereby failing to ensure independence. Furthermore, the State party continues to detain children in immigration detention centers and departure waiting rooms. When deportation orders are issued against parents, children under the age of 14 are detained together with them, resulting in de facto detention of children. From 2020 to May 2025, a total of 886 migrant children were detained in immigration detention facilities. Reported cases include the detention of an 18-year-old child for 631 days and the detention of a one-year-old infant for 141 days.
As of 2024, approximately 60% of refugee applications submitted at ports of entry were subject to inadmissibility decisions. In cases where lawsuits were filed against such decisions, approximately 65% were overturned by courts. Inadmissibility decisions result in refugee applicants being held in airport screening areas or similar facilities under indefinite detention and poor conditions.
…
Since the Korean War, the ROK and the Democratic People’s Republic of Korea have remained under an armistice, and both states maintain legal frameworks that regard each other’s nationals as their own citizens. Based on this unique situation, the ROK has established a legal regime purportedly providing “protection” to North Korean escapees who wish to come and remain in the ROK. However, all North Korean escapees seeking such “protection” are treated as potential spies and subjected to prolonged investigations in secret detention facilities, namely, the Protection Center for North Korean Escapees (formerly the Joint Interrogation Center).
Because the identities of detainees held for extended periods in these secret facilities are not disclosed externally, this practice constitutes a paradigmatic case of enforced disappearance. This is further exacerbated by the fact that the State, particularly the National Intelligence Service, denies that such practices constitute detention at all and denies their susceptibility to habeas corpus proceedings. The UN Human Rights Committee and the Committee against Torture have repeatedly raised concerns in their concluding observations regarding prolonged detention, denial of access to legal counsel, and the absence of procedures to challenge deportation in relation to North Korean escapees.
…
Among the two implementation bills currently pending before the National Assembly, the Kim Gi-hyeon bill that is identical in content to the amendment proposed by the Government during the previous session of the National Assembly limits the scope of victims to “the disappeared person and his or her spouse, lineal ascendants and descendants, and siblings,” thereby defining victims more narrowly than the Convention, which includes “any individual who has suffered harm as the direct result of an enforced disappearance.” Neither of the two implementation bills currently pending before the National Assembly meaningfully reflect the content of Article 24 of the Convention concerning victims’ rights. Instead, they merely contain provisions stipulating the State’s obligations to provide remedies, such as “rehabilitation, restoration of honor, and social reintegration.
…
UN experts have reported numerous cases of human rights violations, including enforced disappearance, in the context of overseas adoption from the ROK. These include the absence of consent from biological parents, the misrepresentation of children as orphans, the falsification of the status of children born to unmarried mothers, and excessive financial gain. UN experts have expressed concern and requested information from the Government regarding case identification, investigation of violations, provision of appropriate reparation, and guarantees of the right to search for biological families.
Although the Government has submitted responses to such inquiries, no meaningful efforts to resolve these human rights violations have been observed. In its 2024 concluding observations on Norway, the Committee on Enforced Disappearances addressed an investigative body concerning past illegal overseas adoptions, and the Republic of Korea was one of the principal countries of origin under investigation.
Of the more than 150,000 overseas adoptees estimated to originate from the Republic of Korea, only approximately 500 cases have been submitted to the Truth and Reconciliation Commission, and only about 50 cases have resulted in findings of human rights violations. Even in these cases, the Government has taken no remedial action.
The newly established Truth and Reconciliation Commission is expected to address not only the approximately 400 cases currently pending, but also a large number of additional petitions. However, the Republic of Korea has made no special preparations to investigate a substantial volume of cases, nor has it established appropriate remedial measures in the event that human rights violations are recognized.”
Written by Pillkyu Hwang